Koetter/Kim – Blackwall Peninsula Projects

In 1997 Koetter/Kim & Associates published a monograph of their work.

cover
Cover of the Koetter/Kim & Associates monograph

The drawings, sketches, and models  shown in their book are excellent examples for any student of urban design, and as a plus, Koetter/Kim share their design process throughout the text.

One of the projects they present is located on Blackwall Peninsula in East London. The site, an approximate 300-acre peninsula formed by a loop of the Thames, lies adjacent to the historical center of Greenwich and, for a number of years, was utilized as a large gas and coal storage site combined with various industrial uses and a small amount of low-scale residential units.

Embedded in the monograph are a series of five hand drawn proposal for Blackwall Penisula. I became very intrigued with these sketches and eventually redrew them in figure/ground format for my text “The Genealogy of Cities.” What’s noteworthy is the identifiable typological names assigned to each of the five schemes. Below are the original hand drawings, preceded by a figure/ground of the site as it existed in 1988.

Blackwall Pennisula:Originals.jpg
The five Blackwall schemes preceded by a figure/ground of the peninsula in 1988

The five typologies used for each scheme are,

  • Manhattan
  • Collision
  • Parks & Canals of German Models
  • Little Cities
  • Central Park

Below are the figure/ground drawings of the five schemes.  After each project a brief explanation of where the idea, related to the title, could have possibly come from.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

Manhattan Model
The Manhattan Model

The Manhattan Model, based after the city of Manhattan, is named due to the orthogonal grid that is dominate in the design.

K:CLASSESFALL 2013URBAN FORMNYC.CAD.fullscale 1 500 (1)
A portion of the city of Manhattan demonstrating the orthogonal grid.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

Collision Model.jpg
The Collision Model

The concept of collision in urban design occurs when the grids vary in direction, and the relationship of proximity and connectivity are offset.  To show the similarity, below is an analysis of the Collision Model compared to the Vienna Ringstrasse of 1914.

Collision Model Comparison.jpg
The fields of collision in the Blackwall project on the left, with colliding fields of the Vienna Ringstrasse project on the right.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

Parks & Canals_German Model.jpg
The Parks & Canals of German Model

The  Parks & Canals of German Model  is fairly self-explanatory.  The illustration below shows the Koetter/Kim scheme compared to the precedent figure/ground of Düsseldorf, 1896.

Parks & Canals_Duselldorf Combo Analysis.jpg
The parks and canals of the Blackwall project on the left, with parks and canals of Düsseldorf, 1896 shown on the right.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

Little Cities Model.jpg
The Little Cities Model

The Little Cities Model is a cluster of definable fields.  It’s possible then to choose a series of small cities, and/or projects, and through manipulation collage these into the existing Little Cities Model produced by Koetter/Kim.  Below are four cities similar in configuration.

Selected Cities.jpg
The top plan is proposed project design by David Chipperfield for Frankfurt(Osthafen), Germany, 1994.  Bottom left plan is Timgad, a Roman-Berber city in the Aurès Mountains of Algeria, 100 AD. Bottom center plan is Neuf-Brisach, France 1729, and bottom right plan is Zamość, Poland, 1578.
Little Cities Model Analysis.jpg
Shown on the left are the four definable fields in the Koetter/Kim project. On the right are the four cities, shown above, inserted with minor manipulations.

———————————————————————————————————————————–

Central Park Model.jpg
The Central Park Model

In the Central Park Model you find solid massing surrounding a park, or void.  This is easily seen in a figure/ground of Manhattan, with a number of the gridded blocks removed to create Central Park.

Manhattan
Figure/Ground of Manhattan illustration the void of Central Park

———————————————————————————————————————————–While teaching I found the act of naming a given urban design project allowed the student to better understand the precedents they chose. Each given title  was always accompanied with analytical sketches of the precedents. Throughout my teaching career I repeatably used the five Koetter/Kim projects, shown above, as examples of how to successfully approach an urban design process. Each time I study these five projects I always discover something new.  I hope you enjoy studying them as much as I do.  I welcome your comments and look forward to possible discussions that may arise.

As a final note.  Here is Blackwall Peninsula as it exist today. It’s my belief it stills needs a better, more comprehensive design.

Blackwall Today.jpg
Aerial of Blackwall Peninsula 2016

 

2 Comments

  1. Dear Sir/Madam,

    I designed two of the schemes (Manhattan and Ideal Cities) above while working with Fred.
    I worked on and off with Fred for 25 years and would be happy to discuss his design process/methodology.

    Best regards, JR

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s